Professional incompetence (insuffisance professionnelle) means a mismatch between the employee’s skills and the requirements of their post. It is not misconduct: it does not fall under disciplinary law. If a dismissal is pronounced, it is a dismissal for personal reasons, which must rest on a real and serious cause, supported by objective and verifiable facts (fiche F2835).
The employer follows the procedure of a preliminary interview and a reasoned letter. The employee is entitled to notice, to the paid-leave allowance and, after eight months’ seniority, to the dismissal allowance. They may bring a claim before the conseil de prud’hommes, which assesses whether the incompetence is established and whether it justifies the termination. An insufficient appraisal, on its own, is not always enough; the facts must be precise.
Official sources
The rules set out here are based on the Service-Public.fr fiches (Directorate of Legal and Administrative Information) and on the Labor Code, available on Légifrance and on the Code du travail numérique. Grounds for personal dismissal (F2835) Procedure (F2839) Allowance (F987)
For a concrete question about your situation, the labor-law information service answers on 0 806 000 126 (free service + the cost of a call, Monday to Friday 9:00 – 11:30 and 13:30 – 16:00). This national number is not the switchboard of an inspection unit. Disputes about the ending of a contract go to the conseil de prud’hommes (labor court). This site is an independent directory, not affiliated with the Ministry of Labor.
